Comparison between Usability and Security in Android Pattern System

The research evaluates the usability and security of different Android patterns across 3x3, 3x4, and 4x4 grids on smartphone authentication mechanisms. Through an experiment with 90 volunteers using a specially created Android application, this study examines the security and usability of the Android pattern lock system. The results show that roughly 70% of participants authenticated on their first try, while only 13% failed to authenticate on their first, second, and third try, indicating that they failed to remember their pattern supply during the experiment, although the Android pattern lock is generally user-friendly, there are significant security concerns, as indicated by the failure rate. The findings advocate for the adoption of larger grid sizes to mitigate brute force and guess-based attacks while maintaining acceptable usability levels.